6 Grading Criteria for the EOS Go Block Producers Reports

KevKev Posts: 399 admin

EDIT APRIL 27 - Please note there are two new criteria starting with Report #9 releasing Wednesday May 16, 2018.

In an effort to help the community review its block producer candidates, EOS Go will continue providing an impartial weekly report to help distinguish excellent candidates. We will do this by asking for criteria requested by the community, and check marks will be earned for any effort by a BP candidate to meet that criteria. EOS Go is not running for block producer and will remain a neutral community empowerment organization.

Our mission for this weekly report:

1) Objectively rank block producer candidates based on public information provided.

2) Streamline voter research and promote radical transparency between candidates.

Criteria: starting March 28, the block producer report will offer candidates a chance to earn up to six check marks for providing information, and candidates will be ranked according to the number of check marks they receive. To receive a check mark, links from the candidate must be shared in the report for open review. Candidates with equal number of check marks will be sorted randomly.

Four of the six check mark criteria can only be met if posted to the Steem blockchain (through Steemit.com, Busy.org, etc.). This encourages transparency and integrity by offering a permanent public record of candidate statements. If you need a Steem account, see instructions near the bottom of this post to get one before the report deadline.

Note: these standards will evolve in subsequent weekly reports.

The Six Check Mark Criteria:

1) Public website URL and at least one social media account (all social media links offered by candidate will be shared in report)

As a public representative of a powerful common resource, a community presence is expected.

2) Links to the following ID information, all posted to the Steem blockchain (either in one post or multiple):

A) Official block producer candidate name.
B) Location of company headquarters.
C) Expected location of servers. 
D) Type of servers (cloud, bare metal, etc).
E) Current employee list and pictures of at least 67% of staff.
F) Relevant background qualifications for at least 67% of staff.

Clear identity of company and employees is important, according to the majority of BP candidates.

3) Estimate of technical specifications and total expenditure for resources by June 3, 2018 - posted to Steem blockchain.

Check mark given for any estimate, modesty encouraged by permanent Steem record. Quality and accuracy of effort judged by the community in public document.

4) Estimated scaling plan for hardware after June 3, 2018 - posted to Steem blockchain.

Rough outlines receive a check mark, open review gauges the effort.

5) Community benefit project outline, only for projects expected to be public by June 3, 2018 - posted to Steem blockchain.

BPs overwhelmingly agreed on the importance of community benefit projects.

6) Listing of Telegram and node names for community testnet participation.

If you still need to join, start at https://t.me/CommunityTestnet

Currently we have 21 candidates signed up on BP candidate form. If you haven't filled out the candidate form you won't be in the report; all candidate names are pulled from the responses.

Important - to earn check marks in the first report please fill out the candidate form if you haven't already and email all links meeting criteria to [email protected] by 23:59 UTC on March 28.

Thank you for providing this information; the community looks forward to learning more about the representatives who will make EOS valuable.

If you need a Steem account it can take up to a week to get an account through Steemit.com, due to initial account funding requirements. To help candidates meet the March 28 23:59 UTC deadline, EOS Go will help any block producer candidate set up an instant Steem account for free; please follow instructions below.

Instructions to Get a Steem Account from EOS Go:

1) Go here to check Steem name availability - https://blocktrades.us/create-steem-account
2) Pay for the name yourself to secure keys, or proceed to step three for EOS Go to get you a free account.
3) For free account, email [email protected] with the following info:
A) Desired available Steem name.
B ) Your Telegram username for private message delivery of keys. You will need to change your keys after receiving them.



  • GunnisonCapGunnisonCap Posts: 14 Jr. Member - 1/5 EOS Tokens
    edited March 2

    Good objective criteria measurements, well done we are fully supportive of this at EOS42 - London based not Korea :)

    EOS42 - Block Producer
    Head of Strategy & Community

    www.eos42.io | @EOS42io / @GunnisonCap on Twitter | @GunnisonCap on Reddit

  • BodgetBodget Posts: 14 Jr. Member - 1/5 EOS Tokens

    @GunnisonCap said:
    Good objective criteria measurements, well done we are fully supportive of this at EOS42 - London based not Korea :)

    Bet you're wishing you had gone with "EOS London" now ;-)
    Best regards

  • CRISPRCRISPR Posts: 1 Brand New

    Thanks BlueJays and Kevin for being proactive on this. I believe you guys are doing a excellent job! I've been keeping a list of my favorite BP candidates to vote for since February. An updated and complete list of BP's will definitely be beneficial come voting time. Have either of you, or anyone else for that matter, found information on how many votes each EOS user will be able to cast for BP(s), and how many tokens will be used for each vote?

  • BodgetBodget Posts: 14 Jr. Member - 1/5 EOS Tokens

    Hi Crispr it is a topic of much discussion but it would appear to be 1 EOS token will give you 30 votes to cast across you favourite BP Candidates. Your token will be locked for 3 days when you vote to prevent the selected BPs changing too frequently.

    Personally I'm still unsure if there is a limit to how many of each 30 votes can be cast for a single BP, I will try and find out and see if we can publish a definitive guide to voting, or if any of the other BPs or indeed if Block.One have created such a guide already.

    Best regards

    EOS Nottingham

  • zoiezoie Posts: 1 Brand New

    hi~ I am a newbie, I I want to know who will decide which candidate was selected.

  • enwenw Posts: 4 Brand New

    very helpful to check the throughout criteria before the submission :) :)

Sign In or Register to comment.
Join Telegram